Project Esther (Heritage Foundation, 2024)
Background
Project Esther is a policy initiative released by the Heritage Foundation in October 2024. It is presented as a “National Strategy to Combat Antisemitism” in the United States.
Goals and Tactics
- Redefines antisemitism to include pro-Palestinian advocacy and criticism of Israeli government policy, framing them as inherently antisemitic and part of a so-called “Hamas Support Network.”
- Proposes aggressive government actions against protesters, educators, and academic institutions, including:
- Deportation of foreign students and faculty involved in pro-Palestinian activism
- Revocation of visas and green cards for pro-Palestinian speech
- Designation of civil society groups as terrorist-linked
- Cuts to federal funding for institutions accused of tolerating antisemitism
- Removal of curriculum and professors seen as sympathetic to Palestinians
- Coordination with states to suppress protest
- Monitoring of student groups and activist networks
Implementation and Impact
- Many proposals are reportedly already being implemented, such as visa revocations, campus funding cuts, and immigration enforcement against student activists.
- Faculty and students have faced disciplinary action, surveillance, and legal penalties for participating in protest or expressing pro-Palestinian views.
- Hundreds of millions in federal funding have been pulled from leading institutions; more than 300 student and faculty visas have been revoked.
- Campus activism is being tracked and treated as extremist behavior.
Criticisms
-
Critics argue Project Esther blurs the line between legitimate protest and hate speech, and ignores right-wing antisemitism.
-
Civil rights and advocacy groups say it criminalizes dissent, erodes academic freedom, and targets pro-Palestinian voices.
-
The initiative is seen as a threat to democratic pluralism and civil society, setting a precedent for criminalizing protest and restructuring the law to punish dissent.
-
Advocacy groups and media (including CAIR and Al Jazeera) describe Project Esther as a blueprint to discredit and dismantle the Palestine solidarity movement in the US, and as a playbook for targeting groups critical of Israel by associating them with Hamas or terrorism.
-
The Nexus Project and others note that Project Esther reframes protest as antisemitism and dissent as a national security threat, leading to disciplinary action, surveillance, and legal penalties for students and faculty simply for participating in protest or expressing pro-Palestinian views.
-
Critics highlight that Project Esther was created in response to growing protests against US support for Israel’s war on Gaza, and that it specifically targets universities, where support for Israel is declining among young people in the US.
-
Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP), named in the report, called Project Esther’s allegations “outlandish.”
-
Rights groups and UN experts have described the context of these policies as part of a broader crackdown on dissent and academic freedom, especially in higher education.
Response
- Organizations like the Nexus Project and CAIR have released strategy documents and statements opposing Project Esther, arguing that the fight against antisemitism must uphold democracy and not dismantle it.
- The initiative has sparked national debate about free speech, academic freedom, and the boundaries of protest in the U.S.