The President generally cannot send the National Guard into Chicago for law enforcement without the consent of Illinois’ governor. However, there are exceptions under federal law:

• The National Guard is usually under state control, and deployment for local law enforcement typically requires the governor’s approval.
• The President may activate the National Guard under federal authority, such as the Insurrection Act, in situations involving insurrection, obstruction of federal law, or if local authorities are unable to maintain public order. This is uncommon and requires specific legal justification.
• The use of active-duty military for law enforcement is restricted by the Posse Comitatus Act, except in cases where the Insurrection Act applies.

Summary: The President can only deploy the National Guard to Chicago without state approval under special circumstances defined by federal law, and such actions are subject to legal and political scrutiny.

Protests in Chicago and National Guard Threats

Overview

In early September 2025, protests erupted in Chicago after President Trump threatened to deploy National Guard troops to the city. The move was framed as a response to violent crime and immigration enforcement, but it was met with strong opposition from state and local leaders.

Key Events

• Labor Day Protests: Demonstrators marched in Chicago, voicing opposition to the threatened deployment and increased immigration enforcement.
• Presidential Threats: President Trump stated he would prefer Governor Pritzker’s consent to send in the National Guard but also said, “we’re going to do it anyway.”
• Focus on Immigration: Federal officials indicated that law enforcement surges would target immigration, especially around Mexican Independence Day (Sept. 16). Some parades and events were postponed due to safety concerns.
• Local Response:
• Governor Pritzker called the threat “an insult to any and every citizen.”
• Mayor Brandon Johnson called the move “illegal and costly,” noting that crime is down and criticizing federal funding cuts for violence prevention.
• Johnson signed an executive order barring Chicago police from collaborating with federal immigration officers or U.S. military on patrols, and requiring police to wear official uniforms.
• Community Actions:
• Volunteers at public events provided whistles and codes for those approached by immigration officers.
• Major events like Taste of Chicago and Printers Row Lit Festival continued with heightened vigilance and reduced attendance.

Political and Legal Context

• The White House criticized local officials for “publicity stunts,” while local leaders argued that the city is safer and that federal support for violence prevention is being cut.
• The situation in Chicago is part of a broader pattern, with similar threats made toward Baltimore and New Orleans. Some state leaders, like Louisiana’s governor, welcomed federal intervention, while others strongly opposed it.

Community Impact

• Concerns over immigration raids and National Guard deployment led to lower attendance at public events and increased anxiety among mixed-status families.
• Community outreach and safety measures were ramped up, with organizations providing resources and support to vulnerable residents.

References

• NPR: How Chicago, Baltimore and New Orleans are reacting to Trump’s National Guard threats
• Democracy Docket: Trump Threatens ‘WAR’ on Chicago
• Fox 32 Chicago: Mexican Independence Day parade postponed due to safety concerns

---

This document summarizes the protests and political conflict in Chicago following President Trump’s threats to deploy the National Guard in September 2025.