This should scare all Americans.
The fact that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) cannot provide a clear justification for Khalil’s arrest is deeply troubling. In a nation that prides itself on the rule of law, due process, and civil liberties, the government’s inability—or refusal—to articulate the specific reasons for detaining a lawful permanent resident raises serious concerns about transparency and accountability.
Deputy Secretary Troy Edgar’s vague response—suggesting that Khalil’s presence at pro-Palestinian demonstrations is reason enough for arrest—sets a dangerous precedent. Participating in political protests is a constitutionally protected right under the First Amendment. If the mere act of demonstrating is grounds for arrest and potential deportation, it represents a significant erosion of civil liberties and a step toward authoritarian tactics where individuals are punished for their political beliefs rather than actual crimes.
Moreover, the claim that Khalil’s visa could be revoked is not only misleading but factually incorrect. As a green card holder, he does not possess a visa that can simply be rescinded by the administration. Any change in his immigration status must go through a legal process, including review by an immigration judge. The suggestion that administrative officials have unilateral authority to strip him of his residency without due process is both legally dubious and indicative of a broader disregard for the rule of law.
The United States does not—and should not—“disappear” people. Arrests must be based on clear legal violations, not vague associations or political participation. If DHS cannot specify what Khalil did that justified his detention, the logical conclusion is that he is being targeted for his activism. This is not how justice is supposed to work in America. If we allow the government to detain individuals without due process or clear charges, we undermine the very democratic principles we claim to uphold.
If you have time to listen to NPR’s Morning Edition with the DHS official, we highly recommend it. Thank you, NPR!
We worry—who is next?
Source